You S01e05 | Aiff

But Joe’s internal monologue reveals the truth: moving in isn’t about protecting Beck. It’s about total surveillance. From her messy closet to her forgotten voicemails, Joe now has 24/7 access to every corner of her life. And he hates what he finds.

That night, while Beck sleeps, Joe slips out and returns to the bookstore basement. Benji is still alive—barely. Dehydrated, terrified, and reduced to begging. Joe ignores him. Instead, he opens his leather-bound journal and begins a new section: Dr. Nicky. you s01e05 aiff

He turns and walks away, disappearing into the New York crowd, already planning his next abduction. The cage isn’t empty for long. But Joe’s internal monologue reveals the truth: moving

The apartment still smells of Benji. Joe finds an expensive bottle of organic mouthwash in the bathroom, a gluten-free cookbook on the shelf, and—most infuriatingly—a half-empty jar of artisanal peanut butter in the pantry. Each object is a silent taunt. Joe’s obsessive-compulsive nature rebels against the chaos, but more than that, he resents Benji’s lingering presence in Beck’s space. He scrubs the apartment top to bottom, not out of kindness, but to erase his rival. And he hates what he finds

He writes down everything he knows: the therapist’s full name (Nickolas Pasternak), his office address, his license number. He starts planning. If Beck won’t stop seeing Nicky voluntarily, Joe will have to remove the obstacle. He looks at Benji, whimpering in the cage, and smiles coldly. “You’re not my biggest problem anymore,” he whispers.