New Scary Movies On Prime May 2026

Slasher purists who miss 2000s horror. 5. The Devil’s Bath (2024 – International Pick) Vibe: Slow, beautiful, soul-crushing

People who think The Hitcher wasn’t stressful enough. 4. Dark Windows (2023) Vibe: Teen slasher with a summer camp hangover new scary movies on prime

Fans of religious horror and jump scares that earn their keep. 2. Bag of Lies (2024) Vibe: Found footage, but make it grief-stricken Slasher purists who miss 2000s horror

Set within a Jewish funeral home in Brooklyn, this one takes a forgotten piece of mythology—the Abyzou, a demonic child-stealer—and turns it into 90 minutes of claustrophobic terror. Think Hereditary meets The Possession . The scares are patient, the atmosphere is thick, and the final act doesn’t let go of your throat. Bag of Lies (2024) Vibe: Found footage, but

If you’ve been scrolling through Amazon Prime Video looking for something to raise the hairs on your neck, you’re in luck. The streamer just added a fresh crop of horror that ranges from psychological slow-burns to full-throttle gore-fests. Here’s what’s new and actually worth your nightlight. 1. The Offering (2024) Vibe: Folklore dread meets family trauma